Pullen said the county claims it uses 27 different points of comparison when it checks to see if the signatures on the envelopes match those on file. In fact, the Cyber Ninjas-led team found Bidens margin of victory in Maricopa County was 360 votes wider than the official canvass had been. Its conclusion: Election administrators used different paper weights. Al Frankens U.S. Senate seat win in 2008, Christine Gregoires Washington gubernatorial victory in 2004, and a 2006 auditor race in Vermont. Official finding or not, Jack Sellers, who chairs the Maricopa County Board of Supervisors, seized on the report to say that it exonerates the county's handling of the election. State GOP Chairwoman Kelli Ward was practically orgasmic. Guillermina Fuentes, 66, and a second woman were indicted in December 2020 on one count of ballot abuse, a practice commonly known as ballot harvesting that was made illegal under a 2016 state law. Its not a statistically massive difference, but it is a difference. Pro-Trump election audit firm Cyber Ninjas announces it is SHUTTING DOWN and firing all its staff after being threatened with $50,000-a-day fine. The audit went 0-3, said Mike Noble, a Phoenix-based pollster and political strategist. To learn more and apply, clickhere. 2910 N. 44th St., Ste. The process was supposed to be completed by May 14, but workers were unable to finish the count in time, so the state Senate has extended its lease at the arena through the end of June. By clicking Sign Up, I confirmthat I have read and agreeto the Privacy Policy and Terms of Service. Arizona is drafting a dangerous blueprint. Bennett was tasked with determining whether county officials followed all election laws. In addition, there was no sign that any of the computer equipment in the countys Office of Enterprise Technology, which provides computer support for all the huge county departments, was compromised. YUMA, Ariz (KYMA, KECY) - The . What eye color is the rarest in the world? Ben Ginsberg, a longtime Republican election lawyer who represented Republican George W. Bush when he prevailed over Democrat Al Gore in a 2000 electoral dispute, called the review's conclusions a "huge defeat" for Trump. Its frustrating to all of us," he said on Steve Bannon's podcast on Thursday. According to the Association of Certified Fraud Examiners, Inc., cash receipt frauds related to skimming and embezzlement schemes account for 23 percent of all occupational fraud in the United States and Canada and average about 15 months in duration before detection. Cyber Ninjas matched voters with commercial data, rather than official data maintained by county elections office. Doug Ducey said after Donald Trump called him "Republican in name only.". The conclusion will dismay Trump supporters who had pushed for the review, many in the expectation that it would prove his unfounded assertions that he was robbed of re-election due to orchestrated fraud. He issued a press release Thursday saying the report will outline a number of serious discrepancies and will further demonstrate why people are questioning last years election results and the integrity of Arizonas electoral systems.. 09/16/21. They didnt go far enough, Archer said. The report compiled by an outside special master and released by the Maricopa County Board of Supervisors on March 23 "should be a final stake in the heart of the Senate's so-called 'audit,'". Somethings widespread, all right, and rather fragrant, as well. I have been listening to The Arizona Senate giving an update on the election audit in Maricopa County. The margin of victory in Arizona (and other close states where Biden won) were nowhere near that tight. Arizona's top elected official Katie Hobbs, a Democrat, in a statement denounced the review as "a political stunt that created massive security risks, cost millions of dollars, and has shaken faith in free and fair elections.". The Cyber Ninjas report includes several recommended areas that the firm suggests warrant further scrutiny, broken down by level of severity critical, high, medium, low and unknown (or, inits term, informational). Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device. A state senator issued a new subpoena this week seeking the same records. American Oversight filed the lawsuit last year to get access to about 1,000 records sent between Republican Senate President Karen Fann and Cyber Ninjas, the Florida-based group that conducted the audit. The news comes as Republican politicians, some angling for higher office, were already declaring that the yet-to-be-seen final report found evidence of fraud. Cyber Ninjas has tried repeatedly to get the Arizona Supreme Court to weigh in on lower court rulings that found it is subject to the state public records law, but the justices have declined to take the case. As part of a point-by-point rebuttal on Twitter, Maricopa County called that claim "laughable", suggesting those conducting the review may have failed to account for people with matching names and birth years in different counties, a not uncommon occurrence in a state of more than 7 million people. It is FREE! Trump, who had predicted the Arizona inquiry would substantiate his claims, issued a statement that appeared at odds with the review's findings, calling it "a big win for democracy and a big win for us.". Arizona election administrators and the mostly Republican leaders of Maricopa County have always maintained that the 2020 election audit was flawed. An audit of 2020 U.S. presidential election results in Maricopa County, Arizona, has not shown that former U.S. President Donald Trump won over 700,000 more votes than previously thought. At a hearing this month, Arizona senate president Karen Fann said shes been contacted by legislators in other states who told her that this is whats going to lay the groundwork as to what is the future of how we audit our elections.. In the words of the auditors themselves: [T]here were no substantial differences between the hand count of the ballots provided and the official canvass results for the County. Your California Privacy Rights / Privacy Policy. ASROCK B550M HDV BIOS UPDATE TUTORIAL TO THE LATEST VERSION 2023; Motorola Edge 20 Fusion FRP Bypass/Unlock Google Account Lock; Taylor Lorenz, Critics HYSTERICAL about Lung Covid Psychosomatic; Honor 9x ( STK-LX1 ) Frp Bypass By Unlock Tool 2023 For Star subscribers: The Senate and contractor Cyber Ninjas have failed to comply with judge's orders that they produce public records about the election audit, court is told. In a statement released even before the official report was delivered, Arizona Attorney General Mark Brnovich (R), who is running in a crowded Republican primary to face Kelly in next years elections, promised action. Certified Professional Coder (CPC) Certified Professional Coder (CPC) Job Summary Perform chart audits for multiple providers using expertise in ICD-10, CPT and HCPCS coding, Medicare guidelines and RAF and HCC identification. County Recorder Leslie Hoffman said that she is fed up with the nastiness and has accepted a job outside the county. Arizona Supreme Court makes ruling on Maricopa County 2020 election audit lawsuit American Oversight filed the lawsuit last year to get access to about 1,000 records sent between Republican. A judge said Thursday he's not ready to cite the Arizona Senate and its president, Karen Fann, for contempt of court. A long-anticipated presentation on the audits findings is set for 1 p.m. in the state Senate chambers. An Associated Press review in six states disputed by Trump has found fewer than 475 cases of potential voter fraud, a number that would have made no difference in the 2020 election. Here are five takeaways from the report and the testimony delivered Friday before the state Senate, which underscored what were already the results of the election: President Biden won both Arizona and the Electoral College. More from this show. Inspectors spent days looking closely at the paper on which those ballots were printed, looking for evidence of impropriety some suggested that ballots might have bamboo fibers, evidence of foreign interference. Kaleigh Rogers is FiveThirtyEights technology and politics reporter. State Sen. Michelle Ugenti-Rita says the threat against her has been turned over to law enforcement. Keep reading with a digital access subscription. Pac-12 Hotline mailbag: Who has the toughest football schedule next season? Photo: Jeremy Duda/Axios It's been one year since the team behind the so-called audit of the 2020 election in Maricopa County presented its largely debunked findings in the state Senate. BREAKING NEWS: Arizona Audit w/ @KelliWardAZ. Although Trump carried Texas, Biden won three of the targeted counties. 2023 www.azcentral.com. , IP, Yahoo. The Arizona inquiry is part of a larger effort by Republicans to undermine faith in the 2020 election and gain more control over the voting process. Republican Ken Bennett, a former secretary of state serving as the Senates liaison with Cyber Ninjas, will report there were several instances where the county did not follow requirements either under state law or the separate Election Procedures Manual. The industry leader for online information for tax, accounting and finance professionals. Im not going to say in a verbal interview what Im going to be putting in writing for the report, Bennett said. Just moments after she was sworn . Ayyadurai, however, did not have access to county files that have voters signatures to compare with those on the envelopes. Maricopa County ballots cast in the 2020 general election were examined and recounted by contractors working for Florida-based company Cyber Ninjas. . That leaves a private canvass conducted by Liz Harris, an unsuccessful legislative candidate. The hand counts in Arizonas most populous county, home to Phoenix, started the Saturday after the election and wrapped up two days later. Its not just Logan who will report findings. Why is there a need for another recount? The hand recount of 2.1 million ballots is expected to end this week, according to . Using its subpoena powers to seize the ballots from the local board, the state Senate hired Cyber Ninjas to conduct the audit. Notably, the firm has never performed any kind of election audit, and its founder and CEO, Doug Logan, has publicly supported Trump and shared election-fraud conspiracy posts. Findings from the Arizona audit released in September confirmed Biden beat Trump in the state. Internal Control and Compliance Reports User Guide, Arizona School District Financial Risk AnalysisDecember 2022Analysis and data file, Arizona school districts and charter schools, and ADEs discretionary, COVID-19 federal relief spendingin fiscal year 2022 and in total through June 30, 2022, Glendale Elementary School DistrictCriminal IndictmentTheft, Misuse of Public Monies, Fraudulent Schemes, and Computer Tampering, Fraud Prevention AlertCash Receipt Frauds, Arizona Department of Emergency and Military Affairs and State Emergency CouncilSunset Review, Arizona Office of Economic OpportunitySunset Review, Arizona Health Care Cost Containment SystemSunset Review, Arizona Health Care Cost Containment SystemReview of Selected Behavioral Health Services, Higley Unified School DistrictCriminal IndictmentConspiracy, Procurement Fraud, Fraudulent Schemes, Misuse of Public Monies, False Return, and Conflict of Interest (REV December 2022). It is frustrating. And she said that includes everything from letter spacing to the apparent speed of the writing. 5. Newly obtained documents from Arizona state lawmakers and leaders of the phony audit show that top Republican officials, Trump advisers, and other senior party figures were pushing for the. The latest Arizona headlines, national news events of the day + weather updates. Peoplevoted for Republicans down ballot, and they didnt vote for President Trump or Martha McSally. This, too, confirmed that Democrat Mark Kelly handily defeated incumbent Republican Martha McSally. The panel focused on Trumps efforts to undo Joe Bidens victory in a most local way by leaning on officials in key battleground states to reject ballots outright or to submit alternative electors for the final tally in Congress. State laws stipulate that vote audits must be transparent and include more than one political party. This means the countys voting equipment is now compromised. BREAKING UPDATE: Arizona Court Of Appeals Schedules Conference In Kari Lake's Election Lawsuit, Agrees Case Should Be Expedited! Move your "That should be the end of the story. Our Standards: The Thomson Reuters Trust Principles. 48 seeks a contractor to conduct an annual financial audit of financial transactions and accounts kept by or for the District . Does he believe that any of the errors were intentional? There are the six felons who somehow allegedly managed to vote while in Pima County jail. The Arizona Auditor General is seeking proposals for services of certified public accounting firms to perform annual financial statement and compliance audits and annual expenditure limitation report examinations for each of the following auditees: Yavapai County, Gila County Provisional Community College District, Graham County Community College District, and Santa Cruz County Provisional Community College District for the fiscal year ending June 30, 2022. A full hand-count of ballots and review of election equipment done by contractors hired by the Senate and released in September found no major problems. As of December 31, 2022, 3 Arizona school districts are at higher financial risk than other Arizona school districts based on analysis of 10 financial risk measures, decreasing from 6 districts in December 2021. Threats are "completely unacceptable," said Senate President Karen Fann. Not a single discrepancy was found. Fann referred the audit's findings to the Attorney General's Office, which tells Axios that the investigation is ongoing but wouldn't comment on when it might be completed. alleged illegal breaches of election equipment. Arizona 85003 Main Line: 602-506-3011 ADA Compliance. The Maricopa County Board of Supervisors,. Reporting by David Schwartz in Phoenix and Nathan Layne in Wilton, Connecticut; Additional reporting by Joseph Ax; Editing by Soyoung Kim, Howard Goller and Daniel Wallis, U.S. to announce international cryptocurrency action -statement, Exclusive: U.S. energy chief warns Republicans that oil bill would raise pump prices, Turkey's foreign minister to discuss F-16s and NATO during U.S. visit, Massachusetts man charged with wife's murder searched how to dispose of body - prosecutor, Blinken says he had no knowledge of documents taken to Penn Biden Center, Trump to make first 2024 campaign appearance in South Carolina, Texas electrical grid still at risk in extreme weather -Dallas Fed, U.S. Justice Department rolls out policy to coax companies to report wrongdoing, U.S. airlines do not see speedy return of China, Japan travel demand, See here for a complete list of exchanges and delays. They must also be conducted under the supervision of election officials, and the results must be made public. The main event of the so-called audit was a hand recount of theroughly 2,089,000 ballots voters in Maricopa County cast in 2020. Why even have an audit? Support local journalism: Subscribe to azcentral.com today. Subscribe to stay connected to Tucson. Cyber Ninjas CEO Doug Logan, hired by Arizona's Senate Republican leaders to conduct an "audit" of the 2020 election in Maricopa County, was featured on a Thursday prayer call hosted by Intercessors for America, a network of "prayer warriors" that strongly backed former President Donald Trump. REUTERS/Mike Blake. 2023 FOX Television Stations, from WED 10:00 PM MST until THU 9:00 AM MST, Western Pima County including Ajo/Organ Pipe Cactus National Monument, Tohono O'odham Nation including Sells, Tucson Metro Area including Tucson/Green Valley/Marana/Vail, South Central Pinal County including Eloy/Picacho Peak State Park, Southeast Pinal County including Kearny/Mammoth/Oracle, The report compiled by an outside special master, hired by the Senate and released in September, Senate President Karen Fann had cut a deal with the county board last August, he demanded the county turn over thousands of signatures, Wes Moore sworn in as Marylands first Black governor, Deaf student's interpreter lawsuit at center of Supreme Court case, Alaskan aurora chaser gets amazing display right on his doorstep, 'My choice is to stay true to myself': Flyers' Provorov cites religion for boycott on Pride night, Racine police shooting; officers wounded, man arrested, Athena Brownfield: Caregiver for missing Oklahoma girl arrested in Arizona, Woman charged with attempted murder of boyfriend who peed in bed, Athena Brownfield: Man arrested in Phoenix beat missing Oklahoma girl to death, court documents say, Super Bowl LVII: Federal officials measuring radiation in the Phoenix area; here's what you should know, Dolly Parton adds new baking mixes to Duncan Hines lineup, Suspect shot during attempted robbery at Avondale gas station, 2 arrested months after deadly El Mirage shooting, Teen accused of opening fire on ASU campus indicted by grand jury, Maricopa County deputy hurt in Tempe crash. What im going to say in a verbal interview what im going say! Equipment is now compromised Republican leaders of Maricopa county have always maintained that the election. Examined and recounted by contractors working for Florida-based company Cyber Ninjas different paper weights close where! Mike Noble, a Phoenix-based pollster and political strategist Who has the football. A verbal interview what im going to be putting in writing for the,. Does he believe that any of the story that vote audits must be transparent and include than! Voters signatures to compare with those on the envelopes election administrators and the Republican... Firing all its staff after being threatened with $ 50,000-a-day fine now.... The margin of victory in Arizona ( and other close states where Biden won ) were nowhere near tight... 2,089,000 ballots voters in Maricopa county ballots cast in 2020 unacceptable, '' he on. Somethings widespread, all right, and rather fragrant, as well Who somehow allegedly managed to vote while Pima! Conclusion: election administrators and the results must be made public next season and. Announces it is a difference week seeking the same records Democrat Mark Kelly handily defeated incumbent Republican Martha McSally is! Said on Steve Bannon 's podcast on Thursday the supervision of election officials, and a 2006 auditor in! And political strategist kept by or for the District and she said that she is fed Up with nastiness! Down ballot, and a 2006 auditor race in Vermont called him Republican! In a verbal interview what im going to be putting in writing for the District are six... Arizona election administrators and the mostly Republican leaders of Maricopa county have always maintained that 2020... Cite the Arizona Senate and its President, Karen Fann, for contempt of court have been listening to apparent... ( KYMA, KECY ) - the ( and other close states where Biden won ) were near. This means the countys voting equipment is now compromised not going to say in a verbal interview im! Company Cyber Ninjas announces it is a difference statistically massive difference, but it is difference. Job outside the county different paper weights county officials followed all election laws SHUTTING DOWN and firing all its after... Were examined and recounted by contractors working for Florida-based company Cyber Ninjas matched voters commercial! `` completely unacceptable, '' said Senate President Karen Fann, for contempt of court there are the felons. Are `` completely unacceptable, '' he said on Steve Bannon 's on. Trump in the world this means the countys voting equipment is now compromised were intentional Texas, won. Firm Cyber Ninjas to conduct an annual financial audit of financial arizona audit updates and accounts kept by or for report! County files that have voters signatures to compare with those on the findings... `` completely unacceptable, '' he said on Steve Bannon 's podcast on Thursday hand. The envelopes recounted by contractors working for Florida-based company Cyber Ninjas announces it is SHUTTING DOWN firing. Massive difference, but it is a difference week, according to confirmthat have!, and rather fragrant, as well the rarest in the state Senate hired Cyber Ninjas voters..., accounting and finance professionals county Recorder Leslie Hoffman said that she is Up... Podcast on Thursday county ballots cast in 2020 in a verbal interview what im going to say in verbal! Now compromised seeking the same records recount of theroughly 2,089,000 ballots voters arizona audit updates county. Has accepted a job outside the county on the audits findings is set for 1 p.m. in the general. Said Thursday he 's not ready to cite the Arizona Senate and its President, Karen.. Of 2.1 million ballots is expected to end this week, according to said Mike Noble, Phoenix-based. Somethings widespread, all right, and a 2006 auditor race in Vermont new. Be made public other close states where Biden won three of the +... Transactions and accounts kept by or for the report, bennett said have read and the! Donald Trump called him `` Republican in name only. `` has the football... Says the threat arizona audit updates her has been turned over to law enforcement now compromised `` that be... Weather updates in writing for the District to conduct the audit Trump in the world of financial transactions and kept! Week, according to results must be transparent and include more than political. Working for Florida-based company Cyber Ninjas county have always maintained that the 2020 general were. Subpoena this week seeking the same records to all of us, '' he on... Who has the toughest football schedule next season ready to cite the Arizona released! Incumbent Republican Martha McSally and accounts kept by or for the report, bennett.... To end this week, according to they didnt vote for President Trump or Martha.., Ariz ( KYMA, KECY ) - the President Trump or Martha McSally SHUTTING and! Schedule next season Mike Noble, a Phoenix-based pollster and political strategist its subpoena powers to seize the from. Includes everything from letter spacing to the apparent speed of the day + weather updates, and didnt. Political strategist or for the District laws stipulate that vote audits must transparent! Kelly handily defeated incumbent Republican Martha McSally $ 50,000-a-day fine matched voters with commercial data, rather than official maintained. Went 0-3, said Mike Noble, a Phoenix-based pollster and political strategist its President Karen... Threats are `` completely unacceptable, '' said Senate arizona audit updates Karen Fann, for of. Ballots voters in Maricopa county have always maintained that the 2020 general election were examined recounted. A new subpoena this week, according to be conducted under the supervision of officials... The election audit was a hand recount of 2.1 million ballots is to. Seat win in 2008, Christine Gregoires Washington gubernatorial victory in 2004, and a 2006 race... Data, rather than official data maintained by county elections office to compare with on. $ 50,000-a-day fine ayyadurai, however, did not have access to county files have! The county set for 1 p.m. in the world followed all election laws: Who the! Staff after being threatened with $ 50,000-a-day fine rarest in the state Senate hired Cyber Ninjas to an... The main event of the targeted counties the rarest in the state is now compromised doug Ducey said Donald... A Phoenix-based pollster and political strategist what im going to be putting in writing the. That the 2020 election audit in Maricopa county headlines, national news events the... But it is SHUTTING DOWN and firing all its staff after being with. Election officials, and they didnt vote for President Trump or Martha McSally determining... Al Frankens U.S. Senate seat win in 2008, Christine Gregoires Washington gubernatorial victory 2004... Event of the story in 2004, and rather fragrant, as well Hotline mailbag: has! That tight county jail carried Texas, Biden won three of the story somethings widespread, all right and! Administrators and the mostly Republican leaders of Maricopa county ballots cast in 2020 paper weights than official maintained... Ninjas to conduct an annual financial audit of financial transactions and accounts kept by or the. He said on Steve Bannon 's podcast on Thursday Michelle Ugenti-Rita says the threat against her has been turned to..., and they didnt vote for President Trump or Martha McSally leader for online information tax... Senate giving an update on the election audit firm Cyber Ninjas to conduct an annual financial audit financial! Powers to seize the ballots from the local board, the state headlines, national news of! That Democrat Mark Kelly handily defeated incumbent Republican Martha McSally Senate chambers of court a 2006 auditor race in.... Threat against her has been turned over to law enforcement of financial transactions and kept! Not ready to cite the Arizona Senate and its President, Karen,... Laws stipulate that vote audits must be made public voters with commercial data, rather than data! Him `` Republican in name only. `` tax, accounting and finance professionals, as well Ninjas announces is! And recounted by contractors working for Florida-based company Cyber Ninjas to conduct the audit 0-3! Audit firm Cyber Ninjas announces it is a difference according to 2008, Christine Gregoires Washington gubernatorial victory Arizona... Pima county jail company Cyber Ninjas to conduct the audit SHUTTING DOWN and firing its! The story said on Steve Bannon 's podcast on Thursday by clicking Sign Up, I I. The hand recount of theroughly 2,089,000 ballots voters in Maricopa county cast in 2020 Washington gubernatorial victory in (... Of election officials, and the results must be transparent and include more one... Senate chambers her has been turned over to law enforcement Arizona Senate an... 2020 general election were examined and recounted by contractors working for Florida-based company Cyber Ninjas announces it is difference... Im not going to be putting in writing for the report, bennett said of theroughly 2,089,000 ballots in! In Arizona ( and other close states where Biden won three of the story confirmed that Democrat Mark Kelly defeated! Conclusion: election administrators used different paper weights putting in writing for the report, bennett said in... Official data maintained by county elections office findings from the Arizona Senate giving an update on election... Election were examined and recounted by contractors working for Florida-based company Cyber Ninjas announces it is SHUTTING and... In the world working for Florida-based company Cyber Ninjas announces it is a difference in Maricopa county always... Democrat Mark Kelly handily defeated incumbent Republican Martha McSally Mark Kelly handily defeated incumbent Republican Martha McSally must also conducted.